The first couple of lines of the Bates and Poole chapter: "Approaches to the Design of Technology-Based Learning" really drew me in from a workplace point of view. I've been working at an education research and development company for the past 6(!) years.
The authors describe Neats as those people who are orderly with project management, using a systems approach. I would think that they are professional and task oriented. I visualize a Neat as someone who has a very tidy desk, and doesn't forget deadlines.
Scruffies on the end of the spectrum, are more creative with their ideas, and tend not to stick to the systematic way of doing things; they are reactionary rather than methodical. Tangential thinking, I would put it. Things always take longer than originally thought. I think of some of my dear colleagues who have desks with papers everywhere, but really they are brilliant and thoughtful people.
In the world of instructional design, I think that a team with both types of workers would ultimately be successful. No man/woman is an island, and no curriculum project can be created by just one person. The introduction of the Neat vs. Scruffy distinction helped me realize that there is no ideal way of doing things. Sure there are systems, and best practices, but people have inherent traits that they will bring to any situation they encounter - Instructional Design included!
P.S. I would say I'm somewhere in the middle of the two groups - sometimes at either end.
I enjoyed reading your post. I can identify most with the NEATS way of doing things. I do realize that some SCRUFFIES are needed to balance out instructional design curriculums.
ReplyDeleteIn 2007 I completed a Cost Analysis course in the face to face classroom environment. There was too much technical material and formulas to absorb in a 2 week time frame. The instructors mentioned to the students that the courses for 2008 and beyond will be split into online and face to face courses. The first portion was conducted online with 60 days to complete. The face to face course was changed to one week.
The instructors said it took two years to redesign the course. It was a colloborative effort with the course instructors, instructional design team etc...
Trudi